Article
Is Your Liability Insurance Program Built for a Difficult Claim Year?
Why stress-testing frequency, severity and aggregate limits together reveals what a single-loss scenario can miss
At a health system’s finance committee meeting, a board member looks up from the healthcare professional liability renewal proposal and asks: “What happens if we have a difficult claim year?”
That question goes beyond whether the program works as designed. It asks how the current structure could affect the organization’s financial exposure across a wider range of loss outcomes. A single severe claim is one possibility, but several significant claims could also occur within the same policy year, creating repeated retained losses and drawing on aggregate protection.
The annual insurance renewal period provides an opportunity to look beyond loss history and test how the liability program could perform across a range of full-year loss scenarios. The analysis can show how much loss the organization retains, how much insurance responds and where the program could begin shifting additional loss back to the balance sheet.
Questions Worth Testing Before Renewal
Before the next renewal, finance, risk, legal and governance leaders should consider:
- How much loss could the organization bear across the policy year?
- How quickly could multiple claims consume the annual aggregate?
- How much protection would remain if a severe claim occurred after other claims had already drawn on the annual aggregate?
- At what point would exhausted per-claim or aggregate limits leave the organization responsible for additional loss?
- Has the organization’s exposure or financial position changed enough to reconsider the current structure?
These questions move the analysis beyond whether a specific limit is sufficient for an individual claim. They help leadership evaluate whether the structure still produces an acceptable financial outcome under a broader range of loss conditions.
Consider the Multi-Claim Year
A single severe claim tells only part of the story. Several significant claims in the same policy year can create repeated retained losses while also drawing on the annual aggregate. If a larger claim follows, its financial impact depends not only on its size, but on how much the organization has already retained and how much insurance remains.
That interaction between frequency, severity and aggregate protection is what a full-year stress test can reveal.
What Changing Loss Patterns Mean for the Stress Test
Recent MagMutual hospital claims experience reinforces the importance of testing a liability program against a range of loss scenarios. MagMutual reviewed more than 36,000 closed hospital claims, comparing claims closed from 2017–2022 with those closed from 2023–2025. Overall claim volume was relatively stable, but the distribution and severity of losses changed.
The analysis found:
- The proportion of closed claims exceeding $5 million approximately doubled in the more recent period.
- Claims in the $2 million to $3 million range remained stable, suggesting the change was concentrated higher in the loss distribution rather than occurring uniformly.
- Among claims that crossed the $1 million threshold, the average amount above that threshold increased by approximately 33%.
- Average ground-up severity, measured as indemnity and expense, rose by 48%.
- Indemnity drove most of the increase. Defense expense was not the primary driver.
- The pattern was not limited to accounts with greater exposure to higher-hazard groups.
The significance lies in how the loss distribution is changing. A greater proportion of closed claims are reaching higher loss levels, while severity has also increased.
These findings should be interpreted with two considerations in mind. Large claims take longer to close, so the more recent period may understate how many will ultimately reach the higher layers. The observation window is also relatively short, and the set of qualifying accounts changes from year to year. The findings should therefore be viewed as directional rather than predictive. They highlight changes in loss patterns across the analyzed claims but do not predict an individual hospital’s experience or determine the appropriate retention or limits for any organization.
Claim Trends Aren't the Only Reason to Reassess
Claims experience is only one reason to reassess the liability insurance program. The organization itself may have changed. An acquisition, new facility or new service line can alter the health system’s exposure mix and the loss assumptions underlying the program. Growth can also happen gradually, leaving retentions and limits in place even as the organization evolves.
Financial conditions and priorities can change as well. Excess pricing can affect the economics of retaining versus transferring risk, while capital priorities and financial capacity influence how much loss the organization can absorb in a difficult year. Leadership’s tolerance for financial variability may evolve, too, changing what constitutes an acceptable outcome. Because these decisions can affect capital planning, liquidity and broader financial objectives, a program that has performed well historically may still warrant another look.
Stress testing brings these considerations together, helping leadership evaluate whether the liability program still aligns with the organization’s exposures, financial position and priorities.
Test Frequency and Severity Together
A practical stress test can examine two factors that shape the program’s financial outcome: how often significant claims occur and how severe those claims become. Looking at those factors separately and together creates four useful scenarios:
Expected: Loss activity broadly consistent with what the organization normally anticipates and funds.
Higher frequency: Several significant claims occur in one policy year, creating repeated retained losses and drawing on the annual aggregate.
Higher severity: One unusually large claim reaches the upper layers of the program and tests the per-claim limit.
Combined frequency + severity: Multiple significant claims occur before a severe loss, testing both the total loss the organization bears and the protection remaining after earlier claims.
The aim is not to predict which scenario will occur, but to understand how the existing structure responds across a range of potential outcomes and whether those results align with leadership’s financial objectives.
How the Same Liability Program Responds Across Four Claim Scenarios
For illustration, assume the same liability program in each scenario: a $2 million self-insured retention (SIR) for each and every claim, with a $10M/$10M excess policy above the SIR, meaning a $10 million per-claim limit and a $10 million annual aggregate. The scenarios below show how different combinations of claim frequency and severity affect what the insurer pays and what the organization bears.
| Scenario | Claims | Insurer Pays | Organization Bears |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expected | 3 claims of $1.5M | $0 | $4.5M |
| Higher Frequency | 4 claims of $2.5M | $2M | $8M |
| Higher Severity | 1 claim of $14M | $10M | $4M |
| Combined Frequency + Severity | 4 claims of $2.5M, followed by 1 claim of $14M | $10M | $14M |
The difference is clearest in the final two scenarios. After four earlier claims have drawn on the annual aggregate, the organization bears $6 million of the same $14 million severe claim, bringing its total retained loss for the year to $14 million. The severe claim has not changed. The amount of protection available when it occurs has.
What a Single-Loss Test Cannot Show
The annual renewal process should test more than whether a liability program can absorb one severe claim. Looking across an entire claim year gives leadership a clearer view of how much financial exposure the organization could retain under different conditions and whether that outcome remains acceptable.
Once leadership understands how different claim years could affect the balance sheet, a more strategic question follows: How much of that exposure should the organization intentionally retain? The next article in the series, How Much Risk Can Your Balance Sheet Absorb?, will examine that question through a health system case study, comparing program structures and the financial implications of retaining additional risk.
Explore Your Liability Program
MagMutual’s Capital Solutions team draws on experience across more than $1 billion in risk managed to help healthcare organizations evaluate complex risk-financing decisions. To explore how your liability program could perform across different loss scenarios, request a program evaluation.
Gabriela Campanella is Head of Capital Solutions, MagMutual Insurance Company.
11/26
Want access to exclusive content and advice?
MagMutual offers a wide variety of industry-leading tools and advice to help healthcare providers mitigate their liability risk. Become a PolicyOwner today.
Learn more about our productsDisclaimer
The information provided in this resource does not constitute legal, medical or any other professional advice, nor does it establish a standard of care. This resource has been created as an aid to you in your practice. The ultimate decision on how to use the information provided rests solely with you, the PolicyOwner.
LEARNING CENTER / CMEs
Policyholders can access their CME credits in the MyMagMutual Learning Center.
MyMagMutual